John Dunn

John Dunn original writing
Book sales
Blog
Thought Pieces
Oxford to Cambridge
Archive
Links
Contact

Blog

Next Entry

Two... is the number of love

Tuesday, 8 October 2024 at 22:01

Tomberg profile on Dr John Dunn. Valentin Tomberg

Two... is the number of love

Like Spinoza, Fichte and Gentile, we can choose monism and argue that there is only one sole being. Or we can choose dualism and see that there are two principles in the world: good and evil, spirit and matter. After all, did not Zarathustra, Prometheus and Jesus of Nazareth epitomise the good confronted by evil? And in the same way that Buber called this dualistic mode the ‘encounter’, (the mode of I–Thou), insisting that it is best described as love, Tomberg also argued that:

Two...is the number of love or the fundamental condition of love which it necessarily presupposes and postulates... because love is inconceivable without the Lover and the Loved, without ME and YOU, without One and the Other.

If God were only One, be that an infinitely distant Jehovah, or the solipsistic ‘I am I’ of the idealist philosophers, or Spinoza’s Substance, he would not be the God of whom John says:

God is love; and he that dwelleth in love dwelleth in God, and God in him. (I John 4:16)

From Child of Encounter

© John Dunn.

Upon reflection

Monday, 7 October 2024 at 22:06

Priestess on Dr John nDunn. Upon reflection

The second tarot card, the High Priestess, is the reflection of the pure act of the Magician card. In short, it is the card that reintegrates the active and passive elements of consciousness. Tomberg explained:

As we have pointed out, one becomes conscious of the pure act of intelligence only by means of its reflection. We require an inner mirrorin order to be conscious of the pure act or to know ‘whence it comes or whither it goes’. The breath of the Spirit - or the pure act of intelligence - is certainly an event, but it does not suffice, itself alone, for us to become conscious of it. Consciousness (conscience) is the result of two principles - the active, activating principle and the passive, reflecting principle.

Once more there are echoes of Coleridge, which are emphasised still further by Tomberg’s parenthetic expansion upon the word consciousness, with the word, conscience.

The Magician’s act can be likened to Gentile’s pure act. Gentile’s pure actin itself, the act of the undifferentiated subject and object, cannot be grasped. It is only its reflection which tenders it perceptible, comparable and understandable or, in other words, it is by virtue of the reflection that we become conscious of it. The fact that Gentile reflected, communicated and fixed his Actualism, or the philosophy of the pure act, in books is evidence of this. Consciousness of the pure act needs more than the act itself. Consciousness, from the Latin conscius, itself from con, a form of com ‘together’ + scire‘to know’ is about knowing something with another, the result of the active, activating principle and the passive, reflecting principle. In order to know from where the pure act of intelligence comes and where it goes, something, or someone is required to reflect it.

From Child of Encounter

© John Dunn.

The pure act cannot be grasped

Sunday, 6 October 2024 at 22:09

First tarot on Dr John Dunn. Le Bateleur

The pure act cannot be grasped

Tomberg suggests a kind of spiritual attunement or atOnement on the part of The Magician, a connection with the Divine – that results, quite literally, in grace-full creativity. In the magician’s deftness of hand, Tomberg presents an analogy of being that is concentration without conscious effort, which is magical. But this standpoint of atOneness is not without its limitations as we have already discovered. Both the genius and the limitations of the Magician are summed up at the beginning of Tomberg’s second meditation as follows:

But the pure act... in itself cannot be grasped; it is only its reflection which tenders it perceptible, comparable and understandable or, in other words, it is by virtue of the reflection that we become conscious of it...

From Child of Encounter

© John Dunn.

Creative spontaneity

Thursday, 3 October 2024 at 20:48

Tarot 1 on Dr John Dunn. Creative spontaneity

In meditating upon the tarot card that has the image of the Magician, Tomberg describes an adept who is perfectly at ease with his craft. What the Magician does with his hands is with perfect spontaneity: it is easy play and not work. The Magician himself does not follow the movement of his own hands, his gaze is elsewhere.

The Magician represents the man who has attained harmony and equilibrium between the spontaneity of the unconscious (in the sense given to it by C. G. Jung) and the deliberate action of the conscious (in the sense of ‘I’ or ego consciousness). His state of consciousness is the synthesis of the conscious and the unconscious - of creative spontaneity and deliberately executed activity. It is the state of consciousness that the psychological school of C. G. Jung calls ‘individuation’, or ‘synthesis of the conscious and unconscious elements in the personality’, or ‘synthesis of the self’.

From Child of Encounter

© John Dunn.

Consciousness is the mystery

Tuesday, 1 October 2024 at 22:23

Tomberg V. on Dr John Dunn. Valentin Tomberg

Consciousness is the mystery

Having travelled the long and hard road to individuation to develop and purify the active element of being, it was hard to accept that consciousness needs another element, a passive element. However, there is no consciousness without these two elements, and the suppression of this duality in the Substance, or the Absolute I of Idealism, must necessarily lead to the extinction not of being but rather of consciousness.

Consciousness is the mystery, not being. Consciousness is where the magic lives and encounter opens the door to it. Where better then to turn than to a Magician, as Valentin Tomberg did in his Meditations upon the Tarot?

From Child of Encounter

© John Dunn.

December 2024
November 2024
October 2024
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
    2 4 5
8
15
25
28    
September 2024
August 2024
July 2024
June 2024
May 2024
April 2024
March 2024
February 2024
January 2024
Website design and CMS by WebGuild Media Ltd
This website ©2009-2024 John Dunn